By Jay Chowdappa, MD, co-founder and CEO, Zynix AI · Updated October 30, 2026
Key takeaways
ACOs miss HEDIS measures because closing a gap is slow, manual work, not because they lack gap reports: lists arrive stale, outside clinical data is missing and outreach is generic. HEDIS gap closure software should reconcile new data continuously, combine each patient’s gaps into one outreach, book the visit, prompt the clinician and confirm closure with evidence.
- Gap reports pulled quarterly are out of date by the time coordinators work them, so staff call patients about care they already received.
- NCQA's ECDS reporting depends on structured clinical data, so ACOs without data aggregation across outside EHRs keep showing gaps that are already closed.
- In the MSSP ENHANCED track, meeting the quality performance standard keeps the 75% sharing rate, while missing it scales savings down or removes them.
- AI agents help by reconciling incoming data continuously, matching outreach to each patient, prompting providers at the visit and confirming closure, within rules the care team sets.
The HEDIS Problem Nobody Talks About Honestly
Here is an uncomfortable truth about HEDIS performance in accountable care: most ACOs know which measures they are failing before the measurement year ends, and they still fail them.
It is not an information problem. Every ACO has gap reports. Most have population health platforms that surface open care gaps in colorful dashboards. The problem is the distance between identifying a gap and closing it -- a distance measured in manual phone calls, fax-based chart chases, fragmented provider workflows, and care coordinators drowning in spreadsheets.
NCQA's ongoing transition to Electronic Clinical Data Systems (ECDS) reporting for Measurement Year 2026 makes this worse before it makes it better. Several measures change this year, including the new Tobacco Use Screening and Cessation Intervention (TSC-E) measure, which is reported through ECDS, and a voluntary ECDS reporting option for Blood Pressure Control for Patients with Diabetes (BPD-E). The data plumbing required to report these measures digitally is non-trivial -- and most ACOs have not built it yet.
Meanwhile, the financial stakes keep rising. For MSSP ACOs, quality scores directly modulate the shared savings percentage. An ENHANCED track ACO that meets the quality performance standard on the APP Plus measure set shares savings at the maximum rate of 75%; one that misses it but meets the alternative standard shares at 75% multiplied by its quality score; and one that misses both is not eligible for shared savings and owes maximum shared losses. On a large savings pool, that is a swing worth real money, driven by whether you closed enough care gaps to hit your quality thresholds.
This article breaks down the five structural reasons ACOs systematically miss HEDIS measures, and how AI agent-driven workflows are changing the math.
Five Reasons ACOs Fail at Care Gap Closure
1. Quarterly Gap Reports Are Dead on Arrival
The standard workflow at most ACOs looks like this: a quality team pulls gap reports from their population health platform or MCO partner, distributes Excel spreadsheets to practice sites, and asks care coordinators to work through the list. By the time the report reaches the coordinator, it is already stale. Patients have been seen elsewhere. Gaps have been closed but not yet reflected in claims. New gaps have opened.
This batch-and-chase model creates a perpetual cycle of working outdated information. A care coordinator calls a patient about a missed A1c test, only to learn the test was completed two weeks ago at an urgent care visit that has not flowed through the claims system yet. Multiply that wasted interaction by thousands of patients, and you begin to see why manual gap closure leaves so many addressable gaps open at the end of a measurement year.
2. Data Fragmentation Across the Provider Network
ACO patients do not stay inside your network. A typical Medicare beneficiary attributed to an MSSP ACO sees several different providers in a year, often across multiple health systems with separate EHR instances. Clinical data from these encounters -- the colonoscopy completed at a gastroenterologist outside your network, the mammogram done at an independent imaging center -- may never make it into your gap report.
For ECDS measures, this fragmentation is especially punishing. Digital reporting requires structured clinical data, not just claims. If the data lives in an EHR you do not have an interface with, the gap stays open in your reporting even though the service was rendered. NCQA's removal of the source system of record (SSoR) requirement helps, but only if you have built the data aggregation infrastructure to collect and normalize clinical data from disparate sources.
3. Care Coordinators Are the Bottleneck, Not the Solution
An ACO care coordinator typically manages a large panel of patients with open care gaps at any given time. Their daily workflow involves reviewing gap lists, calling patients, navigating phone trees, documenting outreach attempts, updating spreadsheets, and chasing down clinical documentation from external providers. Much of that day goes to administrative overhead rather than direct patient engagement.
This is the core paradox: the people responsible for closing care gaps spend most of their time on tasks that have nothing to do with patient care. And when measurement year deadlines approach in Q4, the panic-driven "gap closure sprint" creates burnout, errors, and patient fatigue from over-outreach on already-closed gaps.
4. Outreach Without Intelligence Is Just Noise
Most ACO outreach is undifferentiated. Every patient with an open gap gets the same phone call or letter, regardless of their likelihood to engage, their preferred communication channel, their scheduling constraints, or the clinical urgency of the gap. The result: low outreach response rates for phone-based campaigns and even lower for mail.
Worse, many ACOs lack the ability to coordinate outreach across multiple gaps for the same patient. A patient with open gaps for an Annual Wellness Visit (AWV), a colorectal cancer screening, and a medication adherence review might receive three separate calls from three different coordinators -- or might receive none because each coordinator assumed someone else was handling it.
5. No Feedback Loop Between Closure and Reporting
Even when a care gap is successfully closed, the confirmation loop is broken. A patient completes their diabetic eye exam, but the ophthalmologist's claim has not been processed yet. The ACO's gap report still shows it as open. The care coordinator calls again. The patient is annoyed. The coordinator's time is wasted. And when the claim finally arrives, nobody updates the tracking spreadsheet because they have moved on to the next quarter's list.
This lack of timely feedback creates phantom gaps that inflate open-gap counts, misdirect resources, and erode trust with both patients and providers.
How AI Agents Rewire Care Gap Closure
The solution is not a better dashboard. ACOs do not have an analytics problem -- they have an execution problem. What is needed is a system that acts on data within the rules your team sets, coordinates across workflows, and operates continuously rather than in quarterly batches.
That is the job AI agent architectures are built for. Unlike monolithic analytics platforms, agent-based systems deploy specialized AI agents that each own a specific operational workflow -- data ingestion, gap identification, patient outreach, provider notification, closure verification -- coordinated by an orchestration layer that understands the full care plan.
Continuous Data Ingestion and Reconciliation
Instead of waiting for quarterly claims runs, AI agents continuously ingest data from multiple sources: claims feeds, ADT notifications, EHR clinical data via FHIR APIs, pharmacy dispensing data, and lab results. A reconciliation agent matches incoming data against the active gap registry as it arrives, automatically closing gaps when evidence of completion arrives -- regardless of the data source.
Continuous reconciliation shrinks the list of phantom open gaps, which gives coordinators back the time they had spent chasing gaps that were already closed.
Intelligent Patient Stratification and Outreach
An outreach agent does not just generate a call list. It stratifies patients by gap urgency, engagement probability, preferred communication channel, and scheduling availability. A patient who consistently responds to SMS gets a text with a direct scheduling link. A patient with transportation barriers gets connected to a community health worker. A patient who has ignored three phone calls gets a different approach entirely -- perhaps a provider-initiated conversation at their next scheduled visit.
At PBACO, AI-driven outreach stratification replaced an undifferentiated phone campaign for Annual Wellness Visits (AWVs). The key was not reaching more patients -- it was reaching the right patients through the right channel at the right time.
Automated Provider Coordination
For gaps that require provider action -- ordering a screening, completing a documentation template, submitting a referral -- an AI agent can push structured notifications directly into the provider's workflow. Rather than sending a generic fax listing 47 patients with open gaps (which gets filed in a pile and ignored), the system surfaces the specific gap at the point of care, when the patient is in the exam room.
This shift from batch reporting to point-of-care notification changes provider engagement fundamentally. Providers close gaps because the information is in front of them at the moment it matters, not because they worked through a spreadsheet on a Friday afternoon.
Closed-Loop Verification
Once a gap-closing service is rendered, a verification agent monitors for confirmation across all data sources. It cross-references the scheduled appointment with an ADT notification confirming the visit occurred, matches the visit to a claim or clinical document confirming the service was performed, and updates the gap registry. If confirmation does not arrive within the expected window, it triggers a follow-up workflow.
This keeps phantom gaps from piling up and gives ACO leadership a current, accurate view of their quality position at any point in the measurement year -- not a 90-day-old approximation.
The ECDS Transition: Why This Matters More in 2026
NCQA's push toward fully digital quality reporting through ECDS is not just a reporting format change -- it is a fundamental shift in what counts as evidence of gap closure. Under ECDS, structured clinical data elements (lab values, vital signs, medication lists) must flow electronically. Claims alone are insufficient for many measures.
For Measurement Year 2026, the ECDS changes include:
- Blood Pressure Control for Patients with Diabetes (BPD-E) -- requires structured BP readings from clinical encounters
- Follow-Up After Acute and Urgent Care Visits for Asthma (AAF-E) -- requires documentation of a follow-up visit within 30 days
- Tobacco Use Screening and Cessation Intervention (TSC-E) -- requires structured documentation of screening and intervention
NCQA has already published the next round. For HEDIS MY 2027 it added six measures, including Follow-Up After Positive Colorectal Cancer Non-Invasive Screening Test (COF-E) and Continuous Glucose Monitoring Utilization for Patients With Diabetes (CGD-E), will allow voluntary ECDS reporting for Glycemic Status Assessment for Patients With Diabetes (GSD-E), and lists ten measures as pending retirement, to be removed in its March 2027 technical update. The direction is the same: more measures that depend on structured clinical data.
ACOs that have not invested in FHIR-based data exchange, clinical data normalization, and automated quality measurement will find themselves unable to report these measures at all -- let alone perform well on them.
This is where the infrastructure investment pays compound returns. The same data ingestion and reconciliation pipeline that powers AI-driven gap closure also feeds ECDS reporting. You build it once for operational execution, and you get digital quality reporting as a byproduct.
Quantifying the Impact
Where these workflows are in place, the pattern is consistent:
- Continuous reconciliation removes phantom gaps, so coordinators stop calling patients about care they have already received and quality teams see where they really stand.
- PBACO (see the Palm Beach ACO customer story) uses intelligent outreach stratification for wellness visits, converting the AWV from a compliance checkbox into a clinical data capture opportunity that feeds risk adjustment and gap closure simultaneously.
- Agent workflows let a small quality team manage care gaps across many practice sites in a multi-state ACO network without proportionally scaling headcount.
The common thread: none of these results came from better analytics or prettier dashboards. They came from automating the execution layer -- the thousands of discrete actions between identifying a gap and confirming it is closed.
Building for Continuous Quality: A Practical Roadmap
For ACOs serious about HEDIS performance in 2026 and beyond, here is the infrastructure stack that matters:
Layer 1: Unified Data Platform
Ingest claims, clinical data (via FHIR), ADT feeds, pharmacy data, and lab results into a single normalized data model. This is the foundation for everything else. Without it, you are running gap reports against incomplete data and making decisions in the dark.
Layer 2: Continuous Gap Engine
Run measure logic continuously against the unified data platform. Every new data element -- a lab result, a claim, an ADT notification -- should trigger re-evaluation of applicable measures for the affected patient. Gaps should open and close as new data arrives, not quarterly.
Layer 3: Orchestrated Agent Workflows
Deploy specialized AI agents for outreach, provider notification, scheduling, and closure verification. Each agent works within its domain, under the rules and hours your team sets, and hands clinical questions to your care team. An orchestration layer coordinates the agents: it prevents duplicate outreach, prioritizes high-impact gaps, and adapts strategies based on patient response patterns.
Layer 4: Continuous Measurement and Reporting
Feed the same data platform into ECDS-compliant quality reporting. Track your quality position monthly, not annually. Identify underperforming measures and practice sites early enough to intervene -- not in December when it is too late.
What HEDIS gap closure software should do
HEDIS gap closure software should turn each open measure gap into a completed, documented service: it reconciles new data, decides who to reach, books the visit, prompts the clinician and confirms closure. A gap list alone is analytics; closure is execution.
Start by loading the right measures. HEDIS is NCQA’s measure set, used by health plans; Medicare Advantage Star Ratings for 2026 include Part C measures such as breast and colorectal cancer screening, controlling blood pressure and diabetes blood sugar control. MSSP ACOs report a CMS set instead: in performance year 2026 the APP Plus set asks for five clinical measures (diabetes glycemic status above 9%, depression screening and follow-up, controlling high blood pressure, breast cancer screening and, new for 2026, colorectal cancer screening), the CAHPS for MIPS survey, and two claims measures CMS calculates. Many of these overlap with HEDIS, so one workflow can serve both.
- Reconcile data continuously. Match claims, ADT, lab, pharmacy and outside-EHR clinical data against open gaps as it arrives, so closed gaps drop off before anyone calls the patient.
- Combine gaps by patient. One outreach should cover a patient’s wellness visit, screening and blood pressure check, instead of three coordinators calling separately.
- Reach patients on their channel and book in the same conversation. Voice and text agents can offer times, send reminders and rebook missed visits within the rules and hours your team sets.
- Prompt the clinician at the visit. Show the specific open gaps for the patient in the room, not a list of every patient on a fax.
- Confirm closure with evidence. Match each completed service to a claim, lab result or clinical document, and follow up when confirmation does not arrive.
- Track monthly against the standard. Project each measure by practice site against your contract targets or, for MSSP, the 40th percentile MIPS quality score CMS uses as the performance year 2026 quality standard.
Health plans can see the same approach in HEDIS gap outreach for health plans, and Population Intelligence keeps the gap list ranked as new data arrives.
The Bottom Line
HEDIS care gap closure is not a measurement problem. It is an operational execution problem that most ACOs are trying to solve with measurement tools. The ACOs that consistently hit their quality thresholds -- and capture the full shared savings multiplier -- have moved beyond dashboards to automated, agent-driven workflows that close gaps continuously throughout the measurement year.
With NCQA's ECDS transition raising the data infrastructure bar and CMS tightening the link between quality performance and financial outcomes, the gap between ACOs that automate and ACOs that spreadsheet is about to become a chasm.
By October, three quarters of the measurement year are already gone. The gaps you close in Q4 determine whether you hit your quality targets in December.
Frequently asked questions
Why do ACOs miss HEDIS measures?
Most ACOs know which gaps are open; they miss measures because the work between finding a gap and closing it is manual and slow. Gap reports arrive late, clinical data from outside providers is missing, coordinators lose time to administrative tasks, every patient gets the same generic call, and completed services are not confirmed until claims arrive. Phantom gaps then absorb outreach meant for patients who still need care.
How can an ACO close more HEDIS gaps before year-end?
Work from current data, not a quarterly list: drop gaps that outside claims or clinical records already close, combine each patient’s open gaps into one outreach, and book the visit in the same conversation. Prompt the clinician at the visit and confirm each closure with a claim, lab result or note. Track the projected quality score monthly by measure and site, as ACO programs for TCM, wellness visits and HCC gaps do.
What changed in HEDIS for MY 2026, and what is coming in MY 2027?
For MY 2026, NCQA added ECDS-reported measures including Tobacco Use Screening and Cessation Intervention (TSC-E) and Follow-Up After Acute and Urgent Care Visits for Asthma (AAF-E), made three measures ECDS-only, allowed voluntary ECDS reporting for BPD-E and dropped the source-system-of-record requirement. For MY 2027 it added six measures, including COF-E and CGD-E, allows voluntary ECDS reporting for GSD-E and lists ten measures as pending retirement.
How does quality performance affect MSSP shared savings in 2026?
In the Medicare Shared Savings Program, an ACO must meet the quality performance standard, for performance year 2026 a quality score at or above the 40th percentile of MIPS quality scores, to share savings at its track’s maximum rate, which is 75% in the ENHANCED track. Missing it but meeting the alternative standard scales that rate by the quality score. Meeting neither means no shared savings, and an ENHANCED track ACO owes maximum shared losses.
Can AI agents close HEDIS gaps, and what stays with clinicians?
Agents take on the repeatable steps: reconciling new claims, ADT, lab and pharmacy data against the gap list, contacting patients by their preferred channel, booking screenings and visits, sending reminders and checking that the service shows up in the data, within the rules and hours your team sets. Ordering tests, interpreting results and clinical questions stay with clinicians, and gap analytics ranked into worklists keep staff on the right patients.
Related reading
- How AI Closes Care Gaps: From Identification to Resolution
- AWV Billing: G0438 vs G0439, Required Elements and Eligibility for 2026
- How ACOs Actually Make Money: Shared Savings Mechanics and Where AI Moves the Needle
Source notes
NCQA: HEDIS MY 2026: What's New, What's Changed, What's Retired. https://www.ncqa.org/blog/hedis-my-2026-whats-new-whats-changed-whats-retired/
NCQA: HEDIS MY 2027: What’s New, What’s Changed, What’s Retired (August 3, 2026, updated September 30, 2026). https://www.ncqa.org/blog/hedis-my-2027-whats-new-whats-changed-whats-retired/
CMS: Medicare Shared Savings Program, Shared Savings and Losses, Assignment and Quality Performance Standard Methodology Specifications, Version 14 (April 2026). https://www.cms.gov/files/document/medicare-shared-savings-program-shared-savings-losses-assignment-methodology-specifications-version.pdf-0
CMS: Calendar Year 2026 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule Final Rule (CMS-1832-F), Medicare Shared Savings Program changes (fact sheet). https://www.cms.gov/newsroom/fact-sheets/calendar-year-cy-2026-medicare-physician-fee-schedule-final-rule-cms-1832-f-medicare-shared-savings
CMS: 2026 Star Ratings Measures and Weights. https://www.cms.gov/files/document/2026-star-ratings-measures.pdf
About the author
Jay Chowdappa, MD is co-founder and CEO of Zynix AI. He is a physician, and ACOs led by him generated $300M+ in shared savings before he started Zynix AI to help care teams follow through on what their data already shows.
Zynix AI builds the AI agent infrastructure that ACOs use to automate care gap closure and quality reporting. If your gap closure rate is stuck below 50%, let's talk.